Actually in the article though it says that the ump did NOT say 'you're out'. He didn't call 'swing,' he rang him up with his fist and said, 'You're out.''Sorry, I needed to read the rest of the article. When an umpire calls a guy out and you're the catcher - and I've caught my share of them - he's out. He called him out, and that's what's disappointing. The manager for the Angels said the ump said 'you're out' in an article on ESPN.'It was a swing, our catcher caught it, Doug Eddings called him out, and somewhere along the line because the guy ran to first base, he altered the call. Don't you LOVE baseball? What a beautiful, crazy, silly, cerebral, perfect game. The redirection of the ball comes frome the webbing. There is absolutely NO dirt moving in the replays. I also think the umpires are being a little less than honest to say that the replay is inconclusive. Seems like a lot of little blames to go around, but ultimately the catcher could have put it in his control.In fareness to the catcher that was a huge strikeout and he may have been caught up in the moment. Also, it has been noted by many that it is traditional for the umpire to yell 'no-catch, no-catch' just as it is traditional for them to yell 'out' when the out is recorded. He made a very clear out sign with his fist just as Paul is tossing the ball to the mound, and it followed his right handed strike call. I do think that this particular umpire's gestures are confusing. He even said in the paper that he accepts no blame, which is crap.

Replay media catcher 7 audio sounds bad